We've only had, what, 2 episodes after her death? So far he's been concentrating on Kira. Now that Kira is out of the picture (as far as he knows) MAYBE he'll reflect on things. You people aren't even giving him a chance.


He gave Stellar the shell peice to help her remember him- matter of fact, that was what he said when he did give her to Neo.



I just find this "He could have stolen equipment" line to be utter crap. Shinn is NOT a medical scientist- he would have less of a clue than any of you on what would be needed to keep her alive, and none of you can honestly say what would be needed for her.


Saying it's a copout to give Stellar to people that can keep her alive is utterly heartless, especially in Shinn's case. Leaving her on the Minerva to die was not an option: If it were someone YOU cared for, would you just sit there and watch her writhe and twist and gasp from all the pain and suffering her body was going through? Or would you give her the ONLY chance, no matter how remote, at living she had?

This is even more compounded for Shinn, since he's already had his entire family wiped out in front of him. Leaving her to die scared and in pain is as horrifying to him as it should be to any sane person.