Originally posted by: PSJ
First off saying that Frey's behaviour was acceptable because she saw her father die and Shinn's behaviour is not accepted is hypocritical. Shinn saw his family die right in front of his eyes so if you accept Frey's behaviour you will accept Shinn's. I do not accept either persons behaviour, both let their anger and sadness out on other people but in this case Shinn is far better than Frey. Frey completly used Kira, Shinn doesn't use anyone.

Shinn with boobs is not Lunamaria as their personalities are totally diffrent. That comment was just stupid on your part, did you think it through at all before you posted it?

As for my comment about Frey being a whore, that was not entirely serious. I thought that was rather clear.

No Shinn and Fllay's situations with the death of there family are completely differen't and you obviously did not read my above post. Case 1 we have Fllay who Kira promised to protect her father and he failed in doing so this lead to direct hatred towards Kira at the time and was something we saw dealt with real time.

Shinn on the other hand had this happen 3 years before hand it is not a current event and it is part of his past. He's chosen to feel sorry about himself rather then deal with it and move on. Please note that by the end of GS Fllay has dealt with her issue and moved on unlike Shinn at this point.

As for the Lunimaria/Shinn comment looking at the 2 side by side they are the same character one male and one female. I am not directly relating this to there personalities at this point in the series as we honestly don't know anything about Lunimaria aside from she has a sister. Her parents could have also died in the war there is absolutely no reference to anything about her past in all of GSD to this point. So in is essentially impossible to really relate a one dimensional side character to a main character whom we have a lot of insight into there past.