Some thoughts on Rey

[Motteh]

Originally posted by: splash
But then when Meyrin asks Athrun about the Archangel near the end of the episode he says it hasnt sunk, probably Kira as well. It seems like his hopes of Kira being alive have somehow been reconfirmed. It would seem that only Dullindal and Rey's conversation that Meer overheard could be the only possible reason.

"untill Athrun kills him himself, he will always be alive in Athrun's heart"
the above is more or less a literal quote of Rey's reaction to Dullindal saying that now Kira is dead Athrun would turn around (damn i think i may have lost everyone with that sentence)
and it was already confirmed that the Archangel wasn't sunk, atleast the senior officers knew about it, so it is possible that Athrun knows about it
and he did express a little doubt about Kira being alive

[Splash!]

Maybe there is something wrong with the cellphone subs then coz the conversation goes like

Dullindal: But he no longer exists. Then....
Rey: No, he's alive. Unless he kills him with in his heart.

Now someone please explain this in detail because the way they subbed it wasnt really clear. Are they talking about Kira being alive in Athrun's heart, or Kira actually being alive. And then they talk about someone's whereabouts showing the pictures lunamaria took. Now are these Athrun's whereabouts or Kira's?

What i believed was that Rey knows that Kira is alive and is telling Dullindal that Athrun hasnt killed him in his heart either. I guess this is why Dullindal suggests it is a very troublesome situation because Athrun will definitely try to get in touch with the Archangel. And as for the whereabouts of the particular person, it has to be Kira because why would Dullindal be worried about Athrun's whereabouts as he is right at the base?

[Motteh]

"no he's alive. unless he kills him within his heart"
is in the end the same as "untill Athrun kills him himself, he will always be alive in Athrun's heart"
because it basically means that as long Athrun remains his friend and/or doesn't actually see him die
he will always believe that Kira is alive
atleast that's how i thought they meant it to be taken

edit: also my previous quote (2 posts above this one) might have been slight off cause i did it on memory, i didn't actually rewatch the episode
my apologies for any misunderstandings that came forth because of it

[Splash!]

yes i see your point about that but it still doesnt explain the talk Rey and Dullindal have immediately afterwards about someone's whereabouts.

[Motteh]

well i just rewatched the episode from when Meer bursts into Athrun's room and thus you see the convo between Rey and Dullindal
and as far as i know and can due to the fansubbing is that they talk about acusing "him" (Athrun) and later on when Rey is in Legend Dullindal only says "i'll leave it up to you"
but then again i'm highly depending on what the fansubbers give me so because of different fansubbing groups there might be some misunderstandings
like we have here now

[Dannynonsense]

Originally posted by: splash
yes i see your point about that but it still doesnt explain the talk Rey and Dullindal have immediately afterwards about someone's whereabouts.

there talking about asuran they knew he wasnt in the hangar with the new gundams

Rey And Duillandal are a deadly alliance or unholy whatever lifts you skirt

[Mite Gai]

In the Haro^2Tori^2 sub Rey says, "Unless Athrun kills him himself, he'll always be alive in Athrun's heart." The Cellphone^2 guys are speedsubbing so they are gonna make a few mistakes with grammar, but I trust Haro^2Tori^2's accuracy.