Book: Harry Potter -Half Blood Prince-

[SK]

i got to ask did you read the 6th book chaos? for one thing he didnt need to leave a note telling snape was really on their side because everyone in the order believed he was. dumbledore did not know snape would end up killing him, he didnt know to leave the order a note saying, "hey snape is going to have to kill me, but he is still on our side." also dumbledore didnt have snape make the unbreakable vow, draco's mother did.

i doubt that sirius would call anyone in his family a "blood traiter" that is the term for Purebloods that marry Mudbloods or Half-Bloods, or a non magical person, sirius wasnt a purist.

edit: harry already has a ton of potential, and he also has the information dumbledore passed on him. this is a great weapon since voldemort has no idea harry knows about the horcruxes. i think snape or slughorn will have to train harry in the next book.

[ChaosK]

Originally posted by: SK
i got to ask did you read the 6th book chaos? for one thing he didnt need to leave a note telling snape was really on their side because everyone in the order believed he was. dumbledore did not know snape would end up killing him, he didnt know to leave the order a note saying, "hey snape is going to have to kill me, but he is still on our side." also dumbledore didnt have snape make the unbreakable vow, draco's mother did.

i doubt that sirius would call anyone in his family a "blood traiter" that is the term for Purebloods that marry Mudbloods or Half-Bloods, or a non magical person, sirius wasnt a purist.

edit: harry already has a ton of potential, and he also has the information dumbledore passed on him. this is a great weapon since voldemort has no idea harry knows about the horcruxes. i think snape or slughorn will have to train harry in the next book.

yes i did read this book, i was just saying since there is aa theory that Snape may still be on the side or the order, except after murdering Dumbledore, how in the world would he ever be able to convince the rest of the order that he is acctually on their side? snape was already on thin ice but the order left him alone because dumbledore said so, without dumbledore to explain snape's reasoning, the order would probably kill him if he ever returned to say "i'm really on your side"

and i didnt mean that sirius called his family blood traitors, his parents did though, like he said some people were burned off the family tree like he was. (his mom did that) i was just suggesting that regulus might have been one of the people burned off.

[masamuneehs]

Originally posted by: Chaoskiddo

and i didnt mean that sirius called his family blood traitors, his parents did though, like he said some people were burned off the family tree like he was. (his mom did that) i was just suggesting that regulus might have been one of the people burned off.

Regulus is still on the family tree. Sirius points that out to Harry when Kreecher is trying to save it from being thrown out in Book 5. Apparently his parents died before he did...

And to Deblas: Glad you enjoyed it too. From your post I see you are more or less in the same state I was in after first finishing. Everyone's got their theories and speculations, especially regarding Snape and Horcruxes, so feel free to add some more fuel to the fire.