It does sound like a good reason, but man how bad do they really plan to make Shinn's life...That would make Shinn have lost his parents, sister, Stellar, Athrun & Meyrin(he thinks so at this point anyway), and then finally Luna. Plus the learning of Rey and Gilbert's betrayal would be on the same level as losing these people I think. Seems like Shinn should eventually get a break in life.....