Thank you for banning the Narutard.

And I am attracted to shy girls, but Hinata is so one-dimensional and boring... I never could understand...

Wasn't Ami fro Sailor Moon like one of the most popular girls among male viewers? She was the shy, smart, goody-goody like Hinata (with short blue hari also) who was pretty unremarkable... but i seem to remember people loving her (and by love, i mean lust, as seen in the numerous hentai images to be found all over the web)