Okay, so I thought about this for a while, and it's a real toughie.

Both are really good-- each composed with a total kick ass character from two animes I equally adore, easy-on-the-eyes color schemes, and cool backgrounds.

But I'm going to declare the Ichigo sig as the winner.
First of all, I really like the way how Ichigo is translucent. It gives this whole lingering dreamy feeling and matches perfectly with the flames in the background. Also, I think it's spaced out better than the other one. I can't help but notice this bright streak of light near Kakashi's face, making the whole appearance of that sig look much more clustered. I would elaborate some more if both of them weren't so damn good. Seriously, it was a close one.

And thanks a bunch, NM and Kage. I am so gonna use both of them. [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif[/img]

Edited for spelling. =x