I agree with DF that in the end it is the viewers opinion as to which is better. However, that said I think that if you are a true fan of anime the decesion is a no-brainer...SUBS all the way. I think that there is a huge difference in the quality of the viewing experience when you hear emotion played out by japanese voice actors hired to bring their respective characters to life. Dubs try but fall short by a long way in this sense. Although they try, dub VAs just don't match up in anyway. I do agree that the quality of the subs can make or break a show (re: if all of One Piece was subbed by HK, it wouldn't be as popular as it is). If you can read, then go subbed.