One Piece Manga Discussion: Scanlation/Translated Only

[joker-kun]

Do you guys think now that Brook has his shadow back that he'll join the crew?? He's already said yes once but then took it back since he didn't have his shadow. now that Zoro's got it back for him he has no excuse and he's kind of in debt to the straw hat crew. The other possibility is that he'll return to see that whale (Laboon [thanks Carnage]). I don't see that happening since where the Straw Hat's are on the grand line (already in the New World) it would be very hard to navigate back and extremely dangerous, specially for a single pirate.

I think he'll join, and his role will more or less be a musician (Luffy's been wanting one for awhile). Specially since Brook has already stated he is one.

Anyway discuss;
1.) Whether or not you think he'll join
2.) If he does do you think he'll be a good addition

[Carnage]

I think he will join because Luffy plans to meet up with Laboon in the future anyway. But I'd rather he not join because even though he is a musician the crew already has a swordsman. His humor would be much appreciated though.

[joker-kun]

But I'd rather he not join because even though he is a magician the crew already has a swordsman. His humor would be much appreciated though.

Yeah, I think that was more of an issue before the fight with the legendary swordsman though. After it it's clear that he's not even close to being in the same league as Zoro. So I don't think the two swordsman would be an issue anymore.

[rockmanj]

Maybe he has other fighting skill that he can put to use; i mean technically Nami and Usopp both use pole weapons (but usopp's is long range), and Luffy and Sanji are hand-to-hand fighter, but they each fulfill different roles. So i see no reason why Brook wouldnt join...unless he is killed or something.

[.noname.silent]

I think he will join because Luffy plans to meet up with Laboon in the future anyway. But I'd rather he not join because even though he is a musician the crew already has a swordsman. His humor would be much appreciated though.

fixed...

[Carnage]

I'd rather his fighting style be a little creative. Sanji uses cook moves for his kicking style martial arts, zoro uses three swords, Luffy is made of rubber, Nami uses weather, Usopp doesn't us a gun, etc, etc. The only way in which Brooke really feels special is that move of his where you don't notice that you've been stricken by his blade.

[rockmanj]

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=7NH0WN9T

469.

I love Brook's reactions to everything.