Quote Originally Posted by Xrlderek
I agree with that. But a lot of visual novels don't have an anime counterpart.
It really doesn't matter if it has an anime counterpart or not. It's just about finding a place to place visual novel discussion threads.
Would sticking them in "general anime" with a "Visual Novel:" tag really be organized enough? It might look a bit weird, but I think it is the best option.
If the mods/admins officially state that visual novels are to go in General Anime, then that subforum would be renamed "General Anime and Visual Novels", just like "Books and Manga".

Then it just becomes a thread, like any other new anime thread.


Quote Originally Posted by Nado
That's fine or something like "...: The Game". If the Visual Novel has an Anime counterpart up, then just create another thread for the Anime. Munsu already stated that the Visual Novel and Anime discussions be kept separate:
I agree. Visual Novel and Anime discussions should be separate. However, since I'm not terribly fond of making side-discussion threads like "Comparison of FSN - game and anime", if crosstalk is to happen, I'd like it to be in the game thread instead because:

1) The game usually precedes the anime.
2) If (1) is true, then the game is almost always more comprehensive than the anime.

Spoiling potential is kept to a minimum.