If you'll take notice, Shinta and I made 1-2 post in regard to our OPINION that the anime is not being treated fairly. While the entire first page of the previously connected thread was all LN discussion.
If you and Y really want to go through the trouble of addressing it and putting yourselves at risk for spoilers, that's your business. That was not the main point of the thread, just a very small amount of contents that offended you guys. If Shinta and I really wanted to have a "private" conversation away from any real discussion or criticism, there's this thing call PM.
It was simply frustration expressed by fans of the show, because they feel like the object of their affection is not being treated fairly. Is that really so hard to understand? Must everything that doesn't directly agree with you be some sort of attempt at ridiculing or insulting your opinion?