No, the anime's worst characters present 2 options. Anyone over the age of 7 is supposed to be able to tell that they're wrong.Originally Posted by MFauli
Correct. They're like if the Jews in 1943 got titans, and instead of using them to defeat the Nazis, they used them to genocide every non-Jewish person on the planet.
1.) Meant to write "Floch/Eren".
2.) No, the analogy is that the whole world is nazis, just like for Jews in German KZs, there was only nazis surrounding them.
"She's the only non-loli girl in the show, your honor!" will be my defense in court
Right, which is why your analogy, and your entire argument, is wrong.
Marley is the Nazis. Everyone else is just people conquered by Marley, who are only going along with them because they can't stop them. It's like saying Poland, France and North Africa are Nazis.
If Eren stops the Marleyans, there's no reason for everyone else to keep following their lead. Just like with the Nazis.
And like I said, the anime makes this super obvious. There's a reason why the instant Eren embarks on this course of action, he ceases to be a POV character anymore. Because he's the villain now.
It has been said countless times that whole world wants Eldians gone. Pls cite a single scene where it is made clear that only Marley wants that.
Also: Even if it's only Marley - you just said everyone else was conquered by Marley. So ... duh ...
"She's the only non-loli girl in the show, your honor!" will be my defense in court
Again. By characters that are assholes. You aren't supposed to agree with them.
It's like when Madara says, "Mind controlling everyone inside a giant tree is the only path to world peace." You aren't supposed to go, "Oh, well I guess they better get on up inside that tree there then." for fuck's sake.
Just. Because. A. Character. Says. Something. Doesn't. Make. It. True.
Hey numbnuts. Guess what happens when you liberate someone from their conqueror. They don't stay conquered. See: Poland/France/North Africa/etc. After the Nazis were defeated, those countries didn't STAY Nazi controlled.
The whole start of season 4 shows Marley at war with these other countries. If you get RID of Marley, those countries aren't just going to keep on towing the Marley line.
By the only ones that tell us stuff. You making up stuff inside your mind doesn't make it a valid argument.
The world of AoT can't be compared to our real world 1:1 and you know that. The whole world saw what titans can do when Marley conquered them. They, EVERYONE, want the titans gone. Afaik they all expressed their hatred toward titans. Killing Marley leadership won't remove the world's fear of Eldians. It's irrational, like our real world's hate towards innocent pedophiles: The moment the word "pedophile" is used, people lose all their IQ and become dumb. "Kill them!", "Castrate them!", "Monsters!" - towards innocent people who have never committed a crime. And no, hardly anyone makes a difference between pedo-criminals and innocent people who just happen to have a pedophilic attraction that they don't act upon. This is what it's like with Eldians: Them promising not to attack the world with their titan powers wasn't enough for the world. Thus the world tries to eradicate all Eldians. And that is a sentiment not exclusive to Marley.Hey numbnuts. Guess what happens when you liberate someone from their conqueror. They don't stay conquered. See: Poland/France/North Africa/etc. After the Nazis were defeated, those countries didn't STAY Nazi controlled.
The whole start of season 4 shows Marley at war with these other countries. If you get RID of Marley, those countries aren't just going to keep on towing the Marley line.
"She's the only non-loli girl in the show, your honor!" will be my defense in court
The SHOW is SHOWING you otherwise!
For fuck's sake, GABBY doesn't even want the Eldians dead any more. And she is THE WORST. If they can convince her, they can convince LITERALLY ANYONE. The show is DESPERATELY trying to show you that and you just REFUSE to acknowledge that it's even an option.
And in this metaphor you've crafted, the only way for pedophiles to live in peace is to...murder every non-pedophile on the planet.
Except Marley's plan WASN'T to get rid of the Titans. It was to capture the founder so they can have extra big control over the titans, and the world. They don't want the Eldians dead, they want the re-enslaved.
And, for some inexplicable reason, most of the other countries are okay with this plan. Because Willy Tybur said so, and apparently everyone listens to him.
So yeah, actually, almost nobody wants the Eldians dead. It's pretty much just Zeke and his tiny faction.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote