In alphabetical order!

Abarenbou Kishi!! Matsutarou (Rowdy Sumo) - 2 episodes - Dropped - F
Worst main character ever? I just can't stand this guy to keep watching. He is a terrible person with no redeeming qualities. Even if he gets better, I imagine I'll still hate him.

Akuma no Riddle - 2 episodes - B
The plot doesn't really make any sense, but I'm all for mysterious murder games and the characters are interesting enough.

Atelier - not watched yet - expected D

Baby Steps - 2 episodes - B
A refreshing spin on the typical shounen sports anime with a not-hot-blooded protagonist.

Black Bullet - 1 episode - B
Interesting world (if not hilariously reminiscent of Attack on Titan) and fun characters. We'll see where it goes.

Blade and Soul - 2 episodes - B
I was expecting this to be terrible, but it is actually competent and the over-the-top action scenes are great. I look forward to more people dying in ridiculous ways.

Bokura Minna KawaiSou - 2 episodes - D
I'm not digging this so far, pretty boring with some stereotypical characters.
The MC is totally forgettable.
Also, isn't "kawaisou" an adjective meaning "pitiful" or something? Or maybe it is just something sounding similar.

Captain Earth - 2 episodes - D
I can't believe they're spending so much money on this and it is so bad and full of nonsense.
Between the techno-babble and ridiculous launching sequence that doesn't make any sense and isn't even that cool, I'm pretty disappointed in Bones. Star Driver was at least enjoyable for the ridiculous-factor, whereas this is not.

Date a Live 2 - not watched - expected C
First season was meh, but I like the premise of live dating sim with command center. We'll see if it continues to amuse.

Fuun Ishin Dai Shogun - 1 episode - D
The animation... is there animation? I feel like there is art and they move it around on the screen, but I don't know that I would call it animation. I'm sticking around for at least another because of the voice actors.

Gochumon wa Usagi Desu Ka? - 1 episode - C-
I have nothing against cute girls doing random things, but please try to keep it interesting.

Gokukoku no Brynhildr - 2 episodes - B-
After episode 2, I'm starting to get pretty interested in the plot. We'll see where it goes. I feel like the OP is super spoilery though.

Haikyuu!! - 2 episodes - D
Typical sports shounen hot-blooded characters. I'm sticking around until the practice game in episode 3 and if that isn't good, I'm done.

Hitsugi no Chaika - 1 episode - B+
Poor Chaika and her broken speech. Her awesome rifle and the coffin antics were pretty great. Looking forward to seeing this progress.

Inugami-san to Nekoyama-san - 1 episode - Dropped - F
Even though it was a 3 minute show, I stopped to look how much longer was left 2 minutes in because it was so bad.

Isshukan Friends (1 week friends) - 2 episodes - B
I've read 10 chapters of the manga, and the anime has been pretty faithful so far. I wouldn't expect this to really go anywhere, but it is a nice slice-of-life/happy show. Her memory disorder is also pretty freaking ridiculous/convenient.

Jojo - Stardust Crusaders - 2 episodes - A+
JoJo! JoJo! If only the OP were as good as the original. That's pretty much my only complaint so far.

Kanojo ga Flag - 1 episode - C
Harem incoming? The MC has an interesting power (though it doesn't make much sense) so we'll see where it goes.

Love Live! 2 - 1 episode - C
It is Love Live. You're either in or out at this point. Episode 1 being all about stupid emo-nonsense was lame.

M3 ~Sono Kuroki Hagane~ - unwatched - expecting B/C?
No idea about this, but looking forward to checking it out.

Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei - 2 episodes - C
Magic school isn't very interesting yet. Some weird bro-con vibes and a pretty tropey gary-stu MC. I'll stick around to see what happens though.

Majin Bone - 2 episodes D
This show is bad, I'll start there. I'm mainly watching for the lulz, but it might be better to wait for the English dub in that case.

Mangagaka-san to Assistant-san - 1 episode - B+
I read the whole manga and really liked it for its silliness and silly characters. I'm actually really disappointed this is only 12-ish minute episodes.

Mekakucity Actors - not watched yet - expecting A-/B+
Bring it, SHAFT.

No Game No Life - 1 episode B+
So far so good, if they keep building on what they have it should be very interesting.

Ping Pong - not watched yet - expecting D

Ryuugajou Nanana no Maizoukin (Nanana's Buried Treasure) - 1 episode - B+
I like the art/animation so far. Nanana is an interesting character. Lots of potential plot threads dropped in just episode 1. We'll see if they can deliver.

Seikoku no Dragonar - 2 episodes - D
Pretty awful. Not sure why I'm still watching. Maybe we'll have more tsundere girl.

Selector Infected WIXOSS - 2 episodes - C
I'm waiting for some horrible revelation as to what happens when you lose 3 times. Hopefully they can deliver.

Sidonia no Kishi - not watched yet - expecting C

Soredemo Sekai wa Utsukushii - 2 episodes - B+
Super fast pacing so far! I like Nike a lot, and am interested in seeing how she affects this setting.

Soul Eater Not! - 1 episode - C-
Soul Eater was okay (I'd rate maybe a C or C+ overall). Not has less interesting characters. Can it go anywhere?

Leftovers:
Nisekoi - current - A
SHAFT is doing great on this show. It is typical harem to a T, but very well executed.

Nobunaga The Fool - current - C
I'm in it for the voice actors. Gogo Miyano Mamoru! Tomokazu Sugita is always great, too.


Man, that is a lot of shows. Hoping to drop a few more soon-ish. I'm not even going to watch the other kid shows or otome shows.