Originally Posted by shinta
So what I'm getting is that the memories are not enough to know the truth about someone, hence the point of needing this afterlife game. But then we're not supposed to base our decision on "momentary emotions" that happen during the game? Decim was wowwed by the woman's reveal, and that's in a bad way. He sent her to the void based largely on that. This is evident by the fact that he wondered whether he was wrong - whether his interpretation of the woman's outburst was wrong.Originally Posted by shinta
Regarding the bold part, Nona actually said "Everybody makes mistakes". That's clearly saying Decim made a mistake.
How things should have happened was to have Nona, Decim and nameless girl (from now on known as Kuro) all be arbiters, since Decim alone can't see everything as you said.
I'm getting tired of the pre-game explanations. Watching the OVA, ep1 and ep2 essentially feels like watching the same episode three times.