Is this really silly, though? I think it's part of people's nature to take this, at least partly, seriously. It's basically like indirectly telling them that they have bad taste, which is pretty insulting.
What I'm suggesting is balance, which I believe is no longer present in GW. If AnimeSuki is a praise echo chamber, GW is becoming a rant echo chamber, and I'm inclined to believe the latter is worse.
I'd also like to use your reply as reference to what I'm talking about. By labeling that people taking criticism of something they like as something personal, an idea I mentioned in my own post, as silly, you are indirectly saying that I have silly ideas. I'm used enough to your rather potent statements to shrug it off, but it's still a bit annoying. I think there's a better way to say it, but I can only do my best to plead that others give at least some effort to do that. Each person has their own way of expressing themselves, after all.