i like your theory too...
wait...

Death BOO Z's theory sounds A LOT like my theory from the '224 by inane is out' thread first page:

Originally posted by: benjaminz
maybe kakashi's best friend tried to kill him to obtain the mangekyou sharingan, but failed due to kakshi's super genius, and then gave his eye to kakashi in the end

okay nevermind im shootin crap

haha there goes the 'itachi is good' theory
HmMmMm [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-shocked.gif[/img]
...and in the same thread fourth page Death BOO Z says...

Originally posted by: Death BOO Z
i liked the idea someone presented that Obito tried doing the same thing and that's why Kakashi lost his friends and got the eye...
LoL, maybe I take back the 'okay nevermind im shootin crap' part [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-smile.gif[/img]

anyway, i also like that theory where itachi is a good guy and is out to get that 3rd mangekyou user also, but only because i think itachi is super cool and i want him to be a good guy because that cool older brother image is just like... cool, lol... ;(